Hiring the right people has always been more challenging. With competition for talent heating up and job markets constantly evolving, companies often struggle to attract and retain the best talent. In fact, 54% of candidates have abandoned the recruitment process due to poor communication and response.
Looking for Recruiting Software? Check out SoftwareSuggest’s list of the Best Recruiting Software Solutions.
The right recruitment models can help companies find exceptional candidates efficiently and effectively. In this blog, I have explained the top recruitment models that can help businesses of all sizes attract the right talent.
From my experience, the key to successful hiring is aligning your recruitment approach with your company's specific needs. Whether you're looking for short-term solutions or long-term hires, choosing the right recruitment model can save you a lot of headaches and help you find candidates who truly fit your team.
What are Recruitment Models?
Recruitment models are strategies that businesses use to find, attract, and hire new employees. Consider them as various hiring frameworks, each having special advantages and methods. Whether you’re running a small startup or managing recruitment for a large enterprise, the right model can help you navigate the complex world of talent acquisition.
Some companies prefer to handle everything internally, while others rely on third-party agencies or specialized recruitment services. Understanding the different recruitment models available is key to improving your hiring process and securing top talent.
Types of Recruitment Models
There are different types of recruitment models that organizations can implement, each tailored to different hiring needs and challenges. Below, we explore 8 top recruitment models and their pros and cons that will help you attract the best talent and maintain a competitive edge.
1. In-house Recruitment
In-house recruitment refers to hiring carried out by an organization’s hiring manager and his recruitment team. This model allows the company to maintain full control over the entire recruitment process, from job advertisements to interviews and onboarding. It works well for businesses that have a consistent hiring need and can afford to employ a full-time HR team.
The major advantage is that internal recruiters understand the company culture and can tailor their hiring strategy accordingly. This technique is not suitable for smaller businesses or those with recurrent recruiting needs because it necessitates a large resource investment. In-house recruiting is frequently the best option for companies that value long-term employee engagement and corporate culture.
- Complete control over the hiring process.
- HR Team is familiar with company culture and needs.
- Cost-effective for organizations with continuous hiring needs.
- Both resource- and time-intensive.
- Restricted access to outside talent sources.
- Hiring decisions are impacted by internal bias.
2. Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO)
RPO involves outsourcing part or all of the recruitment function to an external agency. This recruitment model is perfect for companies that don’t have the time or expertise to handle recruitment internally. RPO providers are experts in their field and can offer scalable, customized solutions to meet your hiring needs.
They include innovative tools like the Applicant Tracking System and technologies to improve the effectiveness of the hiring process. In addition to lowering expenses and shortening the hiring process, this technique can raise candidate quality. RPO companies are frequently contacted by businesses that require help filling positions quickly or that suffer seasonal hiring spikes.
- Access to recruitment experts with a wide talent pool.
- Scalable, adapting to fluctuating hiring needs.
- Reduces the internal burden on HR teams.
- Less control over the recruitment processes.
- Upfront costs may be higher
- Potential for misalignment with company culture.
3. Embedded Recruitment
In embedded recruitment, external service provider teams are brought into the organization to work alongside the internal HR team. This hiring model blends the best of both worlds, allowing companies to maintain internal control while benefiting from external expertise. These embedded recruiters understand the specific hiring needs and help execute a targeted recruitment strategy.
It is typically short-term and project-based, making it an excellent option for companies undergoing expansion or working on large-scale projects that require specialized talent. It also allows for flexibility, as embedded recruiters can adjust strategies as company needs evolve.
- Close collaboration with the internal team.
- Fast integration into company culture.
- Flexibility for short-term or project-based hiring.
- More expensive than traditional recruitment.
- Works best for short-term hiring needs.
- Relies on external recruiters who may not fully understand the company’s long-term goals.
4. On-demand Recruitment
As the name suggests, on-demand recruitment is hiring based on immediate needs. Its hiring model works well for businesses experiencing short-term spikes in demand, such as those in seasonal industries. It allows companies to bring in recruiters or recruitment agencies on a temporary basis to fill urgent roles.
On-demand recruitment gives organizations the flexibility to scale up their hiring efforts as needed, without committing to a long-term recruitment process. It’s particularly useful for companies that have variable hiring needs but still want to maintain access to top talent.
- Cost-effective for companies with unpredictable hiring needs.
- Quick response to immediate hiring demands.
- No long-term commitments required.
- Potential variability in recruiter quality.
- Focus on short-term results rather than long-term hiring strategies.
- Less focus on employer branding.
Related Read: Gamification in Recruitment: All You Need to Know
5. Agency Recruitment
Agency recruitment involves working with third-party agencies to fill open positions. Recruitment agencies typically have vast networks of candidates and can help companies fill specialized or hard-to-fill roles. These agencies can be highly effective, especially when you need to fill positions quickly or lack the internal resources to recruit.
However, agency recruitment can be expensive, as agencies often charge a percentage of the hired employee’s salary. Despite the cost, this model is ideal for companies that need to fill roles quickly or are looking for very specific skill sets.
- Access to a broad and specialized talent pool.
- Agencies often work with better speed to fill the vacancies.
- Reduces the workload for internal teams.
- It is expensive due to agency fees.
- Limited control over the recruitment process.
- Agencies may prioritize filling roles quickly over finding the perfect fit.
6. Executive Search (Headhunting)
Headhunting, another name for executive search, is a recruiting strategy used to fill senior roles at the highest levels. Under this model, top candidates for leadership jobs are actively sought after by hiring specialized recruiters.
Executive search companies are adept at locating passive candidates who might not be actively seeking for a new position and frequently possess in-depth business expertise. For businesses trying to fill C-suite positions or other important leadership positions, this methodology is perfect. Although it can be expensive, headhunting guarantees that you will draw in the greatest talent on the market.
- Access to high-caliber candidates who may not be actively looking for jobs.
- Tailored searches for specialized or senior-level roles.
- Agencies often have deep networks for hard-to-fill positions.
- High costs associated with specialized searches.
- Longer hiring process due to the targeted nature of the search.
- Best suited for senior or highly specialized roles, not volume hiring.
7. Contingency Recruitment
Contingency recruitment is a risk-free option where you only pay the recruitment agency if they successfully place a candidate. It is often used for mid-level positions and is highly results-driven. The recruitment agency works on multiple job openings simultaneously, increasing the likelihood of filling roles quickly.
It is popular because it minimizes risk and allows organizations to access a broader pool of candidates without upfront costs. However, since the agency only gets paid upon a successful placement, they may prioritize speed over quality.
- No payment required unless a successful hire is made.
- Multiple agencies can work on the same role, speeding up the process.
- Motivates recruiters to fill roles quickly.
- Agencies may focus more on speed than quality.
- Less emphasis on company culture and long-term fit.
- Limited commitment from agencies since they work on multiple jobs at once.
8. Retained Recruiting
Retained recruiting involves paying a recruitment agency an upfront fee to conduct an exclusive search for candidates. This recruiting model is typically used for senior-level or specialized positions. The agency works closely with the company throughout the recruitment process and is incentivized to find the best possible candidates.
Retained recruiters often have access to more in-depth resources and can dedicate more time to the search, making this model suitable for critical or highly specialized roles. While more expensive than contingency recruitment, retained recruiting often yields higher-quality results.
- Agencies are dedicated to locating the ideal applicant.
- Comprehensive, customized searches ensure exceptional applicants.
- Creates a lasting connection with the hiring company.
- High upfront costs, regardless of placement success.
- Can be a slower process due to the thoroughness of the search.
- Best suited for senior or high-value roles.
Related Read: Recruitment Funnel: Stages & Metrics for Better Hiring
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Recruitment Model
Selecting the ideal recruitment technique for your business requires weighing a number of important considerations. Here’s what you can consider when making your decision:
1. Company size and structure
Larger companies with well-established HR departments may benefit from in-house recruitment or recruitment process outsourcing (RPO), where scalability and internal alignment are crucial. Smaller companies or startups might prefer recruiting models like on-demand recruitment, which offer flexibility without long-term commitments.
2. Recruitment needs
If you’re hiring frequently or for specialized roles, an RPO or embedded recruitment model might be a good fit. For smaller or occasional hiring, on-demand or agency recruitment may be sufficient.
3. Budget
Your budget will play a major role in deciding which recruitment model is best. Contingency recruitment might be ideal if you want to avoid upfront costs, while in-house recruitment is a cost-effective option if you hire frequently.
4. Time-to-hire
If speed is a priority, common recruitment models like agency recruitment or contingency recruitment can often provide quick results. On the other hand, executive search or retained recruitment may take longer but can provide more specialized candidates.
5. Expertise and resources
Does your team have the expertise to manage recruitment in-house, or do you need external support? If your company lacks the resources to handle recruitment effectively, models like RPO or embedded recruitment might provide the expertise you need.
Suggested Read: Top 10 Strategies To Improve Your Diversity Recruiting
Conclusion
Attracting exceptional talent is one of the most important challenges facing businesses today. Selecting the right recruitment model can make all the difference in hiring the right people, whether you’re looking for a quick fix or a long-term solution. By understanding the pros and cons of each model from in-house recruitment to executive search you’ll be better positioned to make informed decisions that suit your business needs.
The key is to evaluate your company’s specific needs, budget, and recruitment goals before selecting a hiring model. By carefully considering these factors, you can develop a recruitment strategy that not only fills roles quickly but also brings the best talent on board.
Khyati Sagar is a seasoned HR and payroll expert with over a decade of experience in the field. She has worked with businesses of all sizes, from small startups to large corporations, helping them optimize their HR and payroll processes. As a passionate advocate for technology-driven solutions, she is always on the lookout for the latest advancements in HR and payroll software. When she’s not working, you can find her hiking or playing basketball with her friends and family.
Upgrade your business operations with modern software solutions tailored to your needs.
